Kiehl’s Facial Cleanser vs Foaming Cleanser: Which Is Best?

Choosing the right cleanser can feel like a big deal. Your cleanser sets the tone for your entire skincare routine. Get it wrong, and you might deal with dryness, breakouts, or that annoying tight feeling after washing your face.

Kiehl’s has been a trusted name in skincare since 1851. The brand offers several cleansers, but two stand out as fan favorites. The Kiehl’s Ultra Facial Cleanser and the Kiehl’s Rare Earth Deep Pore Daily Cleanser (their popular foaming option) often go head to head in skincare discussions.

Both products promise clean, refreshed skin. But they work in very different ways. One focuses on gentle hydration. The other targets deep pore cleansing with a satisfying foam. Your skin type, concerns, and personal preference will determine which one works best for you.

Key Takeaways

• Kiehl’s Ultra Facial Cleanser is a gentle, gel-to-foam formula that works best for normal, dry, and sensitive skin types. It cleans without stripping natural moisture from your face.
• Kiehl’s Rare Earth Deep Pore Daily Cleanser is a foaming cleanser with Amazonian White Clay that targets excess oil, enlarged pores, and buildup. It suits oily and combination skin the most.
• Both cleansers are paraben-free and formulated without harsh sulfates like SLS. Kiehl’s keeps its ingredient lists relatively clean across both products.
• The Ultra Facial Cleanser has a creamy, mild lather while the Rare Earth Cleanser produces a richer foam that feels more satisfying for people who like that deep-clean sensation.
• Price points are similar for both products, making the decision more about your skin’s needs than your budget. A 5 oz tube of either product typically retails around $25 to $32.
• If you wear heavy makeup, neither cleanser is a strong standalone makeup remover. You may want to double cleanse with a micellar water or oil cleanser first before using either product.

Kiehl’s Ultra Facial Cleanser Overview

The Kiehl’s Ultra Facial Cleanser is part of the brand’s beloved Ultra Facial line. This line focuses on long-lasting hydration and gentle care. The cleanser follows that same philosophy.

It has a clear gel texture that transforms into a light, soft lather when you add water. The formula contains ingredients like Squalane, Apricot Kernel Oil, and Avocado Oil. These ingredients help maintain your skin’s natural moisture barrier during cleansing.

This cleanser removes dirt, oil, and surface impurities without leaving your skin dry or tight. Many users describe the post-wash feeling as fresh but still comfortable. That balance is hard to find in a cleanser.

The Ultra Facial Cleanser works for all skin types. However, it shines the most on dry, sensitive, and normal skin. People with very oily skin might feel it does not clean deeply enough for their needs. But for everyone else, it is a reliable daily cleanser.

Pros:

• Extremely gentle on sensitive skin
• Contains nourishing oils like Squalane and Avocado Oil
• Does not strip the skin’s natural moisture
• Works well as both a morning and evening cleanser
• Fragrance is mild and not overpowering

Cons:

• May not remove heavy makeup on its own
• Oily skin types might find it too mild
• The lather is minimal compared to foaming cleansers

Kiehl’s Rare Earth Deep Pore Daily Cleanser Overview

The Kiehl’s Rare Earth Deep Pore Daily Cleanser takes a different approach. This foaming cleanser uses Amazonian White Clay as its star ingredient. White clay is known for its ability to absorb excess oil and draw out impurities from deep within pores.

The texture is a white, creamy paste that foams up nicely with water. It produces a satisfying, rich lather that makes your skin feel thoroughly cleansed. The formula also contains Aloe Barbadensis to soothe and calm the skin during the cleansing process.

This cleanser targets oily skin, enlarged pores, and excess sebum. It is part of the Rare Earth line, which also includes a popular pore-minimizing mask. Together, they make a powerful duo for pore care.

People with oily and combination skin tend to love this product. It gives that squeaky-clean feeling without going overboard. Dry skin types should be cautious, though. The clay-based formula can feel drying if your skin already lacks moisture.

Pros:

• Excellent at controlling excess oil
• Amazonian White Clay draws out pore impurities
• Creates a rich, satisfying foam
• Contains Aloe Vera to soothe skin
• Helps minimize the appearance of pores over time

Cons:

• Can feel drying for dry or sensitive skin
• Not the best choice for winter months if your skin gets dehydrated
• Requires a good moisturizer afterward

Ingredient Comparison: What Goes Into Each Formula

The ingredient list tells you a lot about how a cleanser will perform. Let’s look at what each formula brings to the table.

The Ultra Facial Cleanser relies on emollient-rich ingredients. Squalane is a lightweight moisturizer that mimics your skin’s natural oils. Apricot Kernel Oil softens and nourishes. Avocado Oil provides vitamins E and D along with essential fatty acids. These ingredients work together to protect your moisture barrier while cleansing.

The Rare Earth Deep Pore Cleanser leans on mineral-based ingredients. Amazonian White Clay (Kaolin) absorbs oil and pulls impurities from pores. Aloe Barbadensis calms any irritation caused by the cleansing process. The formula is designed to purify without harsh chemicals.

Both products skip parabens and SLS. Kiehl’s has made a clear effort to keep these formulas relatively clean and skin-friendly. Neither product contains artificial colorants.

The main difference comes down to purpose. One formula nourishes while it cleans. The other purifies while it cleans. Your skin’s needs should guide your choice here.

Texture and Application: How They Feel on Your Skin

Texture matters more than most people realize. A cleanser you enjoy using is one you will actually use every day.

The Ultra Facial Cleanser starts as a clear, lightweight gel. When you add water and work it between your hands, it creates a thin, delicate foam. It feels smooth and slippery on the skin. There is no gritty or heavy sensation. You almost forget you are cleansing because the experience is so gentle.

The Rare Earth Cleanser has a thick, white cream texture straight from the tube. It needs a bit more water to activate the foam. Once lathered, it produces a dense, cloud-like foam that covers the face evenly. It feels like the cleanser is really working on your skin.

Both rinse off easily with lukewarm water. Neither leaves a residue or film behind. However, the post-rinse feeling differs. The Ultra Facial Cleanser leaves skin feeling soft and hydrated. The Rare Earth Cleanser leaves skin feeling matte and clean.

Your personal preference plays a big role here. Some people want that dewy, moisturized feeling. Others want that fresh, oil-free finish. Both experiences are valid.

Skin Type Suitability

Not every cleanser works for every skin type. Here is how each Kiehl’s cleanser matches up.

The Ultra Facial Cleanser is best for dry, normal, and sensitive skin. Its hydrating ingredients protect the skin from moisture loss. People with eczema-prone or reactive skin often tolerate this formula well. It does not trigger redness or irritation for most users.

The Rare Earth Cleanser is best for oily and combination skin. The clay-based formula excels at managing excess sebum production. If you deal with shine on your T-zone or clogged pores, this cleanser addresses those issues directly.

What about acne-prone skin? Both can work, but for different reasons. The Ultra Facial Cleanser is gentle enough to avoid aggravating active breakouts. The Rare Earth Cleanser helps prevent future breakouts by keeping pores clear.

If you have combination skin that shifts with the seasons, you might benefit from owning both. Use the Rare Earth Cleanser in summer when oil production increases. Switch to the Ultra Facial Cleanser in winter when your skin needs extra hydration.

Cleansing Power and Effectiveness

Let’s talk about how well each product actually cleans your face. This is the core purpose, after all.

The Ultra Facial Cleanser handles daily dirt, light oil, and environmental pollutants effectively. It does a good job removing sunscreen and light makeup like tinted moisturizer or BB cream. However, it struggles with waterproof mascara, heavy foundation, and long-wear lip products.

The Rare Earth Cleanser goes a step further. The Amazonian White Clay provides an extra layer of cleansing power. It pulls trapped sebum and debris from inside your pores. This makes it more effective for people who deal with blackheads, whiteheads, and congestion.

Neither cleanser is a true makeup remover. If you wear full-coverage makeup daily, you should use a dedicated first cleanser like an oil or balm. Then follow up with either Kiehl’s cleanser as your second step. This double-cleanse method gives you the best results.

For everyday use without heavy makeup, both cleansers perform well on their own. The difference is simply how deep the cleansing goes.

Price and Value for Money

Skincare can get expensive fast. Let’s see how these two stack up in terms of value.

Both the Ultra Facial Cleanser and the Rare Earth Cleanser come in 5 oz (150 ml) tubes. They typically retail between $25 and $32 depending on the retailer and any ongoing promotions. Kiehl’s often runs loyalty rewards and gift-with-purchase offers that can sweeten the deal.

A single tube lasts most people about two to three months with twice-daily use. You only need a small, dime-sized amount per wash. A little goes a long way with both formulas.

Compared to drugstore cleansers, these are premium-priced products. But compared to other luxury skincare brands, Kiehl’s sits in a reasonable mid-range position. You pay for quality ingredients and a formula backed by decades of skincare expertise.

The value is strong for both products. Neither feels like a waste of money if it matches your skin type. The key is choosing the right one from the start so you do not end up with a product that does not serve your needs.

How to Use Each Cleanser for Best Results

Getting the most from your cleanser requires proper technique. Here are some tips for each product.

For the Ultra Facial Cleanser, wet your face with lukewarm water first. Squeeze a small amount onto your fingertips and gently massage it across your face in circular motions. Spend about 30 to 60 seconds cleansing. Rinse thoroughly and pat your face dry with a clean towel.

For the Rare Earth Cleanser, follow the same basic steps. However, you can let the lather sit on your skin for an extra 15 to 20 seconds before rinsing. This gives the white clay more time to absorb oil and impurities. Do not leave it on too long, though. It is a cleanser, not a mask.

Both products work best with lukewarm water. Hot water can strip your skin. Cold water does not open pores effectively. Lukewarm hits the sweet spot.

Always follow up with a toner, serum, and moisturizer after cleansing. Clean skin absorbs your other products better. This is where the real benefits of a good cleanser show up in your overall routine.

Long-Term Results and Skin Improvements

Consistency matters in skincare. Here is what users typically report after weeks of regular use.

Ultra Facial Cleanser users often notice their skin feels more balanced and hydrated over time. The gentle formula allows the skin barrier to stay intact. This reduces redness, flakiness, and sensitivity. After about four weeks, many people say their skin looks plumper and healthier.

Rare Earth Cleanser users report smaller-looking pores and less oiliness after consistent use. The clay gradually removes buildup that stretches pores out. Blackheads on the nose and chin tend to decrease noticeably within three to six weeks.

Neither product will transform your skin overnight. But both deliver reliable, steady improvements with daily use. They set a strong foundation for the rest of your routine to work effectively.

Some users even combine both cleansers. They use the Ultra Facial Cleanser in the morning for a gentle start. Then they use the Rare Earth Cleanser at night for a deeper clean. This approach works especially well for combination skin.

Who Should Choose the Ultra Facial Cleanser

This cleanser is your best bet if you fall into certain categories.

You should pick the Ultra Facial Cleanser if your skin is dry, dehydrated, or sensitive. The nourishing oils in the formula will protect your skin from moisture loss. You will not experience that uncomfortable tight feeling after washing.

It is also a great choice if you prefer a minimalist, no-fuss routine. The gentle formula does not require extra steps to counteract dryness. You can cleanse and move on to your moisturizer without worry.

People who live in cold, dry climates will appreciate this cleanser during fall and winter months. Harsh weather already strips moisture from your skin. A gentle cleanser helps you avoid making things worse.

If you are new to Kiehl’s or to a proper skincare routine, the Ultra Facial Cleanser is a safe starting point. It is hard to go wrong with a formula this mild and effective.

Who Should Choose the Foaming Cleanser

The Rare Earth Deep Pore Cleanser suits a different set of needs.

Choose this cleanser if you have oily skin that produces excess shine throughout the day. The Amazonian White Clay will help regulate that oil production and keep your face matte for longer. You will notice less midday grease on your T-zone.

It is also ideal if clogged pores and blackheads are your main concerns. The clay pulls impurities from inside pores, giving you a deeper clean than a standard gentle cleanser can provide.

People who live in hot, humid climates will find this cleanser especially useful. Heat and humidity increase sebum production. A clay-based foaming cleanser helps counteract that effect and keeps your skin feeling fresh.

If you enjoy the sensory experience of a rich, foamy lather, this cleanser delivers. Sometimes skincare is about enjoyment too. A product you love using is one you will stick with long-term.

Final Verdict: Which Kiehl’s Cleanser Wins

There is no single winner here. The best cleanser depends entirely on your skin type and goals.

The Kiehl’s Ultra Facial Cleanser wins for gentle hydration and everyday comfort. It is the safer choice for most skin types. It cleans effectively without disrupting your skin’s natural balance. If you value softness and simplicity, this is your cleanser.

The Kiehl’s Rare Earth Deep Pore Daily Cleanser wins for oil control and pore care. It provides a more thorough cleanse that targets specific skin concerns. If you want your cleanser to actively fight oiliness and congestion, go with this one.

Both products represent Kiehl’s commitment to quality ingredients and effective formulas. You really cannot go wrong with either choice as long as it matches your needs. And remember, you can always switch between the two as your skin changes with the seasons.

FAQs

Can I use both Kiehl’s cleansers in the same routine?

Yes, you can. Many people use the Ultra Facial Cleanser in the morning and the Rare Earth Cleanser at night. This gives you gentle hydration during the day and a deeper clean before bed. Just pay attention to how your skin responds and adjust if you notice any dryness.

Are these cleansers safe for acne-prone skin?

Both cleansers can work for acne-prone skin. The Ultra Facial Cleanser is gentle enough to avoid irritating active breakouts. The Rare Earth Cleanser helps prevent future breakouts by keeping pores clear. Neither contains salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide, so they will not replace acne treatment products.

Do these cleansers remove waterproof makeup?

Neither cleanser is strong enough to remove waterproof makeup on its own. You should use a dedicated makeup remover or cleansing oil first. Then follow up with your Kiehl’s cleanser as a second step for the best results.

How long does one tube of Kiehl’s cleanser last?

A 5 oz tube typically lasts about two to three months with twice-daily use. You only need a small, dime-sized amount each time. Using too much product does not improve the cleansing results and wastes the product faster.

Are Kiehl’s cleansers cruelty-free?

Kiehl’s does not test on animals where it is not required by law. However, the brand sells in markets like China, where animal testing may be required for imported cosmetics. This is an important factor for consumers who prioritize strict cruelty-free standards.

Can teenagers use these Kiehl’s cleansers?

Yes, both cleansers are gentle enough for teenage skin. The Ultra Facial Cleanser works well for teens with normal or dry skin. The Rare Earth Cleanser is better for teens dealing with oily skin and early signs of clogged pores. Always patch test a new product first.